Assignment 11 - Paper Review

Pick a paper from SIGCHI or another approved source. Send it to the instructor, and then write a review of the paper given the following criteria.

• A paragraph summary of the paper. Include the problem, solution, and main contribution.
• What is the key nugget of information that makes this paper great? (The intellectual contribution)
• What methodology did the authors use to uncover their findings?
• What did this paper do well, do you challenge any of the results? (That is, do you challenge the idea, not the authors directly).
• How would you improve on this paper? (i.e. what project would you collaborate on next with these authors)

Change Log, Guidelines, and update

Provide a list of changes if you have made any. Also spend time updating your guidelines document from the previous assignment. If you have made any major changes in your assignment, include a brief paragraph or bulleted list as well.

Assumptions

Throughout your assignment, state any assumptions that you may have. In each catagory, the goal is that this is self-evident, but you may add additional information as you see fit.

Organization

Please use bulleted lists and tables where appropriate. Start to think of your deliverables as a blueprint, such that another team in the class could follow along with your project. Use pictures, video, and add elements as you see appropriate. Be sure to cite all references!

Grading Rubric and Submission

You will submit your homework as a pdf directly to Mike for this assignment.

The following rubric will be used to evaluate your work:

• Quality of Review: 100 pts